Wawa Settlement Gift Card Review – Is the Wawa $5 eGift Card Legit?

Wawa Settlement Gift Card Review – Is the Wawa $5 eGift Card Legit?

User avatar placeholder
Written by Eva Collins

November 21, 2025

Recently, many people have been talking about an unexpected email claiming to offer a $5 Wawa settlement eGift card.

The email comes from WawaeGiftCards@cashstar.com and says it’s part of the Wawa Data Security Litigation from 2020.

Naturally, surprise offers like this raise suspicions. Viewers want to know: is this legitimate, or is someone using Wawa’s name to scam customers?

What the Email Claims

The email promises that recipients can claim a $5 Wawa eGift card as part of the settlement. It includes:

  • A link to claim the card
  • Wawa branding and logos
  • Reference to the official settlement

At first glance, it looks official—but appearances can be misleading.

Major Concerns and Red Flags

Even though this looks like free money, there are some warning signs shoppers should be aware of.

  • The images are blurry, and the graphics feel low quality
  • The layout doesn’t match Wawa’s usual branding
  • Unexpected emails claiming rewards or settlements can often be phishing attempts

Because of these concerns, many users were unsure whether to click the link at all.

What Users Found Online

Reddit threads and Wawa community discussions provide a clearer picture:

  • Multiple customers who participated in Wawa stores in 2019 confirmed receiving the email
  • Some successfully redeemed the $5 card via the official Wawa app
  • Former Wawa employees confirmed that the settlement itself is real, though the email design is handled by CashStar, which explains why it looks unusual.

How to Safely Redeem the Card

To avoid risks:

  1. Do not click directly from the email right away
  2. Search the settlement name online for official confirmation
  3. Manually redeem the card through the Wawa website or app
  4. Avoid entering sensitive personal info unless you’re on the verified Wawa/CashStar page

These steps help ensure your personal information stays secure while claiming legitimate rewards.

Final Verdict – Legit or Scam?

The $5 Wawa settlement eGift card appears to be legitimate, even if the email looks suspicious.

The main takeaway is that email formatting and design shouldn’t be the only factor when judging legitimacy.

Always cross-check with official sources before clicking links or entering personal information.

While this card is real, a cautious approach ensures you stay safe online.


Leave a Comment